05.02 First steps in litigation

05 International Litigation and Alternative Dispute Resolutions

Collect the facts

Every litigation starts with the collection of facts – by the person or company that wants to enforce its rights. The aim is to document the case and, above all, to secure the evidence: contracts, e-mails, chat messages, photos, delivery notes, invoices. What cannot be proven later does not exist in court (!).

Keep quiet

People and companies involved in litigation must be careful about what they say about the case to third parties, especially to the media and on social media. Not only in criminal proceedings: everything you say can be used against you later. In legal matters, every statement is weighed on the scales. Going into litigation is like war: one wrong move, and you’re dead!

Talk to your lawyer first

If a legal dispute arises, discuss the matter with an internal or external lawyer as soon as possible – before you contact the other party – to determine the course of action. Internal lawyers are bound by business confidentiality, external lawyers by legal privilege. That is why you can and must be completely open with your own lawyer: he or she must also know what speaks against you, in order to be prepared for the arguments of the other side.

Inform your insurer

If the case may involve claims for damages against yourself, or if the case is covered by a legal protection insurance (see Chapter 07.12), the insurance company must be informed as soon as possible. Insurance policies usually set strict deadlines for reporting a case – whoever reports late risks losing the cover.

Try to settle

At any stage of the dispute, try first to settle the matter by negotiation, i.e. by an agreement with the other party. Going to court is the worst case (!), costing money, time and nerves. Even if you win, the compensation awarded by a court does not fully cover the costs you actually incurred.

Exercise: what do you reply?

Rigi Roasters AG (Lucerne) has delivered 20 coffee machines to Hotel Seefeld in Milan. Three days later, the hotel manager writes on WhatsApp:

1 · Marco (Hotel Seefeld, Milan) · Tue 08:41
Four of your machines broke down already. Clearly faulty 😡 Just admit it and we keep the last instalment, ok?
2 · You (Rigi Roasters AG) · Tue 08:42
[your reply]

Write your reply in message 2 (max. three lines). Then check it against the five steps above: Which facts do you need first? What must you not write? Whom should you call before answering? Compare your reply with your neighbour’s.

05 International Litigation and Alternative Dispute Resolutions