Personal data must be processed lawfully (Art. 6 para. 1 FADP; Art. 5 para. 1 lit. a GDPR). A processing is lawful if there is a reason that the law accepts. The three most important reasons are:
- Consent: the person concerned agrees to the processing.
- Overriding interest: for example, a company needs the data to conclude or perform a contract with the person concerned.
- Law: a law requires or allows the processing.
Consent has limits. In my opinion, not every processing of personal data is permissible just because the person concerned agrees to it. Digital platforms such as WhatsApp get their users to disclose almost everything about themselves, because whoever refuses is cut off from their social contacts. Here the law protects people from themselves: nobody can «surrender their freedom» (Art. 27 CC). The GDPR takes the same line: consent must be «freely given» (Art. 4 no. 11 GDPR).
How strictly the rule applies depends on the country:
- EU: processing is prohibited unless the GDPR allows it; every processing needs a legal basis (Art. 6 GDPR).
- Switzerland: processing by private persons is permitted as long as the data protection principles are respected; a reason is only needed if they are not (Art. 30 and 31 FADP).
- USA: processing is generally permitted, unless a specific law prohibits it.
