07.10 Punitive damages

07 Liability Law

Coffee cup with the printed warning «Caution, handle with care, I'm hot»

The most spectacular liability trials take place in the USA. This is mainly because large companies can be ordered in a civil case not only to compensate for the actual damage, but in addition to pay so-called punitive damages, a penalty payment. This payment is set by the courts at a level high enough to ensure that the liable companies effectively change their harmful behaviour. One of the best known and most illustrative cases is the «McDonald’s Coffee Case», even though it was finally settled by agreement. In this case, a woman in the USA suffered severe burns because of a (too) hot coffee. Although there were several such cases, McDonald’s neither brewed the coffee less hot nor did it warn against the hot coffee. Meanwhile, McDonald’s coffee cups contain at least one warning that cannot be overlooked (s. picture; details: Liebeck v. McDonald’s Restaurants, Wikipedia).

Swiss liability law does not know punitive damages: damages only compensate the loss actually suffered. According to the Federal Supreme Court, a penal element contradicts the general principles of assessing damages (BGE 122 III 463, E. 5c/cc).

07 Liability Law