Case «McDonald’s coffee case»

07 Liability Law

Case

Study the «McDonald’s coffee case» (Liebeck v. McDonald’s Restaurants, Wikipedia).

Task

  • Arguments: Extract the main arguments of the parties and their lawyers.
  • AI as opponent: Let a chatbot of your choice (Claude, ChatGPT & Co.) argue first for Ms Liebeck, then for McDonald’s. Which arguments does it add, and which facts does it get wrong?
  • Your country: How would the case be decided in your country? Consider fault, product liability and punitive damages.

The relevant chapters are 07.04, 07.06 and 07.10.

In class: Discuss the case and these arguments in class.

07 Liability Law