05.D International Litigation and ADR – Cases
Case

SwissSolar AG, a company based in Zug, Switzerland, sells solar panels to BrightSun Ltd., based in London, UK. The contract between the parties contains the following clause: «All disputes shall be finally settled by arbitration in accordance with the Swiss Rules of International Arbitration of the Swiss Arbitration Centre. Seat of arbitration: Zurich. Language: English. Applicable law: Swiss law.»
After delivery, BrightSun claims that part of the panels are defective. SwissSolar denies this and demands full payment. BrightSun threatens to file a lawsuit in London, arguing that arbitration in Switzerland would be too expensive. SwissSolar, however, wants to start arbitration proceedings in Zürich.
Both companies would like to continue their business relationship and are considering whether mediation could help them reach a settlement without going to court.
Tasks
Time: about 30 minutes, self-study. Use a chatbot of your choice (Claude, ChatGPT & Co.). Answer six questions:
- Terms: Briefly explain what is meant by international litigation, mediation and arbitration, and how they differ.
- London: What is the legal effect of the arbitration clause if BrightSun sues before a London court anyway – and what can SwissSolar do about it?
- Pros and cons: Compare the main advantages and disadvantages of arbitration in Zurich with ordinary court proceedings.
- Enforcement: SwissSolar wins in Zurich. Can it enforce the arbitral award against BrightSun in the UK – and would that also work with a judgment of a Zug court?
- Economics: From an economic perspective, why could mediation be an attractive option for both companies?
- Decision: As a manager of SwissSolar, which path would you recommend – litigation, arbitration or mediation – and why?
The relevant chapters are 05.01, 05.03 and 05.05. In class: we compare the recommendations in question 6 – and check whether the chatbot knew that the UK is no longer part of the Lugano Convention.
